How Freight Brokers Should Actually Evaluate AI Tools (Beyond the Hype)

AI has become the latest buzzword in freight brokerage. Everywhere you look, software providers are claiming their AI-powered tools will revolutionize the industry. But how do you know if an AI solution actually delivers value for your brokerage, or if it's just marketing hype?

Many freight brokers are asking the same questions:

• How do I evaluate AI software?
• Will AI replace my team, or just help them?
• If it doesn’t replace people, how do I measure ROI?

The truth is, AI won’t magically transform your brokerage overnight. It’s not going to replace your employees. What it can do is help your team scale more efficiently, reduce time-consuming manual tasks, and improve service levels. But only if you choose the right tool.

This article will give you a clear, no-BS framework for evaluating AI solutions so you can make smart decisions, not just buy into the hype.

‍

What AI Will (and Won’t) Do for Freight Brokers Today

Let’s set the record straight:

• AI isn’t replacing jobs today, it’s augmenting them. It allows brokers to scale without hiring as many people, but it doesn’t eliminate the need for skilled employees.
• AI is moving at an exponential pace, and roles at brokerages will shift over the next 2-3 years. The brokers who actively explore AI solutions today will have a competitive edge over those who don’t.

The key to success? Using AI to make your brokerage smarter, not just more automated.

‍

How to Evaluate an AI Solution (3 Key Questions Every Broker Should Ask)

Rather than jumping into AI without a clear strategy, start by asking yourself these three questions:

1. Where is your team wasting the most time on repetitive tasks?

AI is most effective when it reduces low-value, time-consuming work, freeing brokers to focus on higher-impact activities like carrier relationships and revenue growth. When deciding on a solution, remember that you are not buying AI, you are buying an outcome for your business. Consider where automation would drive the most impact for your brokerage.

Ask yourself:

• Where is my team spending most of their day on repetetive tasks?
• What tasks create the biggest bottleneck?
• Where do delays or inefficiencies lead to unhappy customers, late updates, missed tracking, slow responses?

Lesson: The decision to purchase AI should be based on where your brokerage feels the most pain. There is no one-size-fits-all AI solution, only the right AI for your brokerage’s biggest pain points.

‍

2. How does this AI solution fit into my brokerage’s workflow?

Not all AI tools are created equal. Some are plug-and-play, offering quick setup but only automating a narrow set of tasks—like answering phone calls. Others require deeper integration, which takes more effort upfront but empowers users throughout the entire load lifecycle, not just at one step.

Before committing, ask:

• Does this AI empower my team at every stage, or does it only automate a single task?
• Is it a short-term fix with immediate efficiency, or does it offer long-term, scalable improvements across workflows?
• Is it designed for a brokerage of my size, or built for a much different operation?
• How does it integrate with my existing tech stack to enhance our workflow?

Lesson: AI that only automates one step (like answering calls) might save minutes, but AI that assists users across procurement, tracking, exception handling, and carrier communication saves hours. The key is knowing what tradeoff makes sense for your brokerage: a quick fix or a tool that scales with your business.

‍

3. Can I measure ROI, or is this just "AI for AI’s sake"?

Measuring AI’s impact can feel tricky, especially in the early stages. Unlike traditional software, where ROI is often tied to direct cost savings, AI creates value through efficiency gains, better decision-making, and workflow automation.

Instead of expecting an instant transformation, look for early indicators of AI’s impact, such as:

• Time savings: How much faster is your team completing routine tasks? Example: “Average time to retrieve a load status update decreased from 5 minutes to 30 seconds.”
• Reduction in manual interventions: How often does someone need to step in during the load lifecycle? Example: “AI automation reduced manual status check calls per load from 4 to 1, cutting broker intervention by 75%.”
• Scalability: Can your team handle more freight without increasing headcount? Example: “Each broker is now managing 20% more loads with the same team size.”‍
• Improved response times for carrier and customer interactions: Example: "Average response time for carrier inquiries decreased from 10 minutes to under 1 minute."

Lesson: Even if you can’t measure ROI down to the dollar, AI should create noticeable efficiency gains. If an AI vendor can’t explain how their solution improves brokerage operations, be skeptical.

‍

Common AI Use Cases for Brokers (And When They Work Best)

Not all AI solutions are equal. Here are three major areas where AI is currently making an impact:

1. AI-Powered Quoting

• Best for brokers who run predictable lanes with strong pricing intelligence.
• Not as effective if your business relies on high-touch pricing strategies.

2. AI Voicebots for Carrier Calls

• Works well in a loose market where brokers get flooded with inbound calls.
• Less useful in a tight market where finding capacity is the bigger challenge.
• Works well for automating inbound calls but does not assist brokers throughout the entire load lifecycle, leaving gaps in carrier engagement, relationship building, track & trace, and follow-ups.

3. AI Tracking & Visibility

• Reduces check calls and makes sure brokerage SOPs are followed
• Improves service quality by ensuring updates are ready for your customers before they ask.
• AI-Powered Visibility is one of the most consistent and impactful AI applications in brokerage today.

Lesson: Focus on AI that provides tangible efficiency gains in the long-term, not just flashy automation.

‍

How to Implement AI: Start Small, Test, and Scale

Instead of rolling out AI across your entire brokerage on Day 1, start small and measure results:

• Choose a low-risk use case (e.g., automating check calls).
• Run a 30-day test. Measure impact.
• If it works, expand. If not, cut your losses and move on.

Lesson: The best AI solution is the one that delivers real value and goes beyond single task automation—not the one with the flashiest demo. AI works best when it’s deeply embedded into brokerage workflows, not just an extra tool.

‍

Final Thoughts: AI is Here to Stay, But Not Every Tool is Worth Your Time

As AI reshapes the freight brokerage industry, brokers who adopt the right AI solutions will gain a competitive edge. But that doesn’t mean every AI tool is worth investing in.

• Avoid AI for AI’s sake. Pick tools that truly solve brokerage pain points at your brokerage.
• Measure impact. Even basic tracking of time saved helps.
• Start small, scale smart. Don’t overhaul your entire workflow overnight, test, then expand.